When host Richard asked Phoenix and Gaga if the movie lived up to their own expectations, the duo simply exchanged a glance and then burst into quiet laughter. The internet has been buzzing ever since, with fans reacting in every way possible—posing questions, sharing speculations, and, of course, flooding social media with memes.

Lady Gaga will likely take on her first supporting actress Oscar run for “Joker: Folie à Deux.” But how far can “Mother Monster” take a movie with such abysmal reviews? “Joker: Folie à Deux” picks up with Arthur Fleck ( Joaquin Phoenix ),